Restored 'Race Films' Find New Audiences

Mar 4, 2016
Originally published on March 4, 2016 5:55 pm

It's nearly impossible to see some of the earliest movies by African-American filmmakers. Many have been lost or destroyed. Those that have survived are often held by private collectors or stored away in old film archives.

More than a dozen of those movies, though, are now part of a film restoration project — Pioneers of African-American Cinema — by independent film distributor Kino Lorber.

The project focuses on a genre called "race films" — movies made after World War I and through the 1940s by black filmmakers with mostly black casts for black audiences. These films tried to uplift the image of African-Americans and contradict the racist stereotypes in D.W. Griffith's The Birth of a Nation, a blockbuster after its release in 1915.

Many race films exist today only as fragments of decomposing film strips. Some of the few film negatives and prints that are still intact are in an underground vault in Culpeper, Va., where the Library of Congress stores almost 140,000 cans of highly flammable nitrate film shot before 1951 — including The Birth of a Nation's original negative.

"Film is a physical artifact. It can fade. It can shrink. It can crumble to dust in less than a lifetime, and it's a race against time around here," explains Mike Mashon, who heads the moving image section of the Library of Congress. "It's genuinely a miracle that those [race] films survived."

A 'Long History' Behind The Camera

More than 30 companies were producing race films at the height of their popularity during the 1920s. One of the most prolific filmmakers to emerge, Oscar Micheaux, was the son of former slaves. After working as a Pullman porter, he homesteaded in South Dakota and published novels before he wrote, directed and distributed almost 40 movies in three decades. One of his first silent films, Body and Soul, featured the silver screen debut of Paul Robeson, who played an escaped convict pretending to be a minister.

"This race film material presents an extremely important chapter in the long history of African-American participation behind the camera," says Jacqueline Stewart, a film professor at the University of Chicago who helped curate the films in the restoration project.

Micheaux and other race-film directors worked outside of Hollywood, forging indie filmmaking at its earliest stages with low budgets.

"Audiences chuckled at the time," Stewart says. "They would giggle because the acting was so bad. The editing seemed so rough. You know, the quality of the film stock doesn't seem to be all that clear, crisp."

Still, Stewart says they put issues relevant to the black community on screen – "the politics of skin color within the black community, gender differences, class differences, regional differences especially during this period of the Great Migration."

One of Stewart's favorite films in the project is The Blood of Jesus, a 1941 film that was rediscovered in a Texas warehouse in 1983. Actress Cathryn Caviness plays Sister Martha Ann Jackson, a churchgoing black woman in the South who is fatally shot after her husband's rifle falls to the floor and goes off by accident. Her spirit wavers between following an angel to heaven or an agent for Satan to hell, which looks like a jazz club in the city.

Stewart says the film's writer-director — Spencer Williams, who went on to play Andy in the 1950s TV series Amos 'n' Andy­ -- touched on a debate within the black community about city versus country living. "We get this kind of allegory of black urban migration and the dangers that urban life presents and the need to hold on to a certain kind of spiritual center," she says.

'Brilliant' Filmmaking

The restoration project added new sequences to Micheaux's 1939 remake of his silent film Birthright. The first two of the film's nine reels have been missing for years. To replace about 20 minutes of those missing first scenes, restorers have added new title cards to introduce the story of Peter Siner (played by Carman Newsome) — a young black man who graduates from Harvard University and returns home to the South to build a school for African-American children.

New scores have been commissioned for the silent movies, including Micheaux's Within Our Gates. The new soundtrack aside, restorers plan to restore the 1919 film closer to Micheaux's original vision. One of the shots in a lynching scene was upside-down originally, according to Charles Musser, a co-curator for the collection who also teaches film at Yale University. But he says previous film restorers who worked on the film turned it right-side up.

"They thought it was a, quote, 'mistake.' But Oscar Micheaux's mistakes are never mistakes," Musser explains. "This is a moment when, in fact, the world is turned upside down. He shows that by turning the shot upside down. See, now that's like brilliant filmmaking."

It's filmmaking that should not stay sitting in film archives, according to Paul Miller, also known as DJ Spooky, the project's executive producer.

"It's a shame that it's taken almost 100 years to get these films back out," says Miller, who also composed new scores for Within Our Gates, Body and Soul and other silent films. "They should be well-known, and they should be part of the basic premise of early American cinema, period."

Four race films, including Birthright and Williams' 1946 film Dirty Gertie from Harlem, U.S.A., are returning to the big screen at New York City's Film Forum for special screenings on Sunday and Monday. The entire collection of restored race films will be available for streaming online and as a five-disc set in July.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:

You know, it's almost impossible to see some of the earliest movies by African-American filmmakers. Many are lost or destroyed. Those that survived are often held by private collectors or stored away in old film archives. Now some of those movies are being restored. NPR's Hansi Lo Wang has been tracking them down.

HANSI LO WANG, BYLINE: If you're trying to find a rare film, a good place to start is in this underground vault in Culpeper, Va., near the foothills of the Blue Ridge Mountains. This is where the Library of Congress stores more than 100,000 reels of film shot before 1951. "Casablanca," "Citizen Kane," "Mr. Smith Goes To Washington" - they're all behind these locked doors. So are a few movies from a genre called race films. They were made by black filmmakers with mostly black casts for black audiences after World War I and through the 1940s. Many tried to uplift the image of African-Americans and contradict the racist stereotypes in D. W. Griffith's "The Birth Of A Nation." That film is also stored in this vault, just a few slots over from a 1939 race film that George Willeman, the vault's manager, pulls from the shelf.

GEORGE WILLEMAN: This is a reel of "Birthright" - Oscar Micheaux film.

(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, "BIRTHRIGHT")

WANG: "Birthright" is about a young black man who graduates from Harvard and goes home to the South to build a school for African-American children. When he tries to buy some land, he gets cheated by a white man in a fictional town called Hooker's Bend.

(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, "BIRTHRIGHT")

CARMAN NEWSOME: (As Peter Siner) Why, that can't be legal.

ALEC LOVEJOY: (As Tump Pack) Legal? Legal hell - anything a white man wants to pull over on a Negro in Hooker's Bend is legal.

WANG: The first scenes of the movie have been lost for years. Archivists say that's lucky, because many of the race films now only exist as fragments of decomposing filmstrips. That's why Kino Lorber, an independent film distributor, started a project called Pioneers of African-American Cinema to restore more than a dozen race films. Jacqueline Stewart, a film professor at the University of Chicago, is helping to curate them.

JACQUELINE STEWART: This race film material presents an extremely important chapter in the long history of African-American participation behind the camera.

WANG: There were more than 30 race film companies by the 1920s. One of the most prolific filmmakers that emerged, Oscar Micheaux, was the son of former slaves. He wrote, directed and distributed almost 40 movies in three decades. This was indie filmmaking at its earliest stages - outside of Hollywood and with very low budgets.

STEWART: Audience chuckled at the time. They would giggle because the acting was so bad, the editing seemed so rough, you know, the quality of the film stock doesn't seem to be all that clear - crisp.

WANG: Still, Stewart says they put issues relevant to the black community on screen.

STEWART: The politics of skin color within the black community, gender differences, class differences, regional differences - especially during this period of the Great Migration.

(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, "THE BLOOD OF JESUS")

UNIDENTIFIED ACTRESSES: (As characters, singing) There's a long white robe in heaven, I know.

UNIDENTIFIED ACTORS: (As characters, singing) There's a long white robe in heaven, I know.

WANG: One of Stewart's favorites in the collection is a 1941 film that was rediscovered in a Texas warehouse in the 1980s, "The Blood Of Jesus."

(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, "THE BLOOD OF JESUS")

CATHRYN CAVINESS: (As Martha Ann Jackson, screaming).

WANG: A rifle falls to the floor, goes off by accident, and kills a young black woman in the South. Her spirit wavers between following an angel to heaven or an agent for Satan to Hell, which looks like a jazz club in the city.

CAVINESS: (As Martha Ann Jackson) Oh God, have mercy on my soul.

WANG: Stewart says the film's writer-director, Spencer Williams, touched on a debate within the black community about city versus country living.

STEWART: We get this kind of allegory of black urban migration and the dangers that urban life presents and the need to hold onto a certain kind of spiritual center.

(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, "WITHIN OUR GATES")

WANG: New scores have been commissioned for the silent movies, like Oscar Micheaux's "Within Our Gates," from 1919. This latest restoration is more faithful to Micheaux's original vision, according to Charles Musser. He's a co-curator for the collection and teaches film at Yale University. And he says one of the shots in a lynching scene was originally upside-down. But when previous film restorers worked on the film...

CHARLES MUSSER: They turned it right-side up because they thought it was a, quote, "mistake." But Oscar Micheaux's mistake are never mistakes. This is a moment when, in fact, the world is turned upside down. He shows that by turning the shot upside down. So that's, like, brilliant filmmaking.

WANG: Filmmaking that Paul Miller, the collection's executive producer, says should not stay sitting in film archives.

PAUL MILLER: It's a shame that it's taken almost 100 years to get these films back out. They should be well-known, and they should be part of the basic premise of early American cinema, period.

WANG: Some of these films are returning to the big screen at New York City's Film Forum this Sunday and Monday. The entire Pioneers of African-American Cinema collection will be available for streaming online, and as a five-disc set, in July. Hansi Lo Wang, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.